Making History Hollywood Style

Making History Hollywood Style

Articles - Directing

For better or worse, movies are the closest thing
we’ve got to a cultural Rorshak test. Like Rorshak’s inkblots, movies
are infinitely interpretable, and the way we view a given film often
tells us more about ourselves than it does about the film in question.
So it follows that when a filmmaker manages to tap into our deepest
emotions as a society, he’s telling us an awful lot about our cultural
psychology.

In recent weeks,
just about everyone I know has been talking about Steven Spielberg’s Schindler’s List, and what a great film it is. One particularly
cynical friend, who has never been a fan of Spielberg’s particular
brand of schmaltz, and who is also one of the most insightful film
critics I know came out of the film saying, "Well, I guess
pigs can fly." Now, I’ve never been a big Spielberg fan either,
but I admired his two previous efforts at adult filmmaking (The
Color Purple
and Empire of the Sun), and I’d like to
think I approached the film with an open mind. Because I’m descended
from European Jews, I’m pretty sure I approached it with an open
heart- there’s nothing I’d rather see than a great film about the
Holocaust.

Steven Spielberg with Liam Neeson on location
in Poland.

But when I finally got around to seeing Schindler’s List this weekend, I wasn’t overwhelmed. Yes,
I was impressed with Spielberg’s technical achievement and I was
certainly moved by the uplifting and life-affirming story he chose
to tell. And the performances by Liam Neeson, Ben Kingsley, Ralph
Fiennes and the rest of the cast were remarkable. But ultimately,
I walked out of the theater disappointed.

Schindler’s List contained
as many parts commercial entertainment as it did cinematic art,
which helped make it a great Steven Spielberg movie, but not a great
movie. Looking at what many of us consider to be the defining tragedy
of the twentieth century, Spielberg managed to make a film that
in many ways fits comfortably into an ouever that also includes E. T.

Liam Neeson as Oskar Schindler, who protected
Jewish workers in Nazi-occupied Poland.

Much of my disappointment has to do
with the film’s context. It’s one of only two major Hollywood movies
in recent years to deal directly with the Holocaust. For my money,
the other one, Sophie’s Choice, was a much more powerful
film. It seems to me that the title character of Sophie’s Choice,
a woman forced to decide which of her two children will have to
die at the hands of the Nazis (and who ultimately takes her own
life because she cannot live with the fact that she made the choice),
is a much more potent and fitting symbol for the Holocaust than
the title character of Schindler’s List, a man who risked his life
and squandered his fortune to save 1,100 Jews who would otherwise
have perished. (Interestingly, neither of these two symbols of the
Holocaust are Jewish.) The thing is, I don’t want to be uplifted
by a story about the Holocaust. I want to horrified. Granted, there’s
plenty of horror in Schindler’s List, but it’s a question
of balance. Is Spielberg giving us a spoonful of sugar with our
medicine, or is it the other way around?

Indeed, there were several moments
in Schindler’s List that were so undeniably sentimental that
they made me cringe. Schindler’s transformation from opportunist
to humanitarian comes when he watches the destruction of a Jewish
ghetto from the remove of a distant hilltop. He’s transformed, however,
not by the mass cruelty he witnesses, but by the ordeal of one little
girl (wearing a red coat in an almost entirely black and white film)
who wanders through the chaos to her doom. Children, of course,
have always been central to Spielberg’s vision (e.g. E.T. and Hook), but here his strategy seems painfully manipulative.
Even more manipulative is Schindler’s final scene, in which he chastizes
himself for not having done more to save the Jews. Coming after
we have learned that Schindler has lost his entire fortune to his
efforts, this breakdown rings utterly false.

I was also bothered by Spielberg’s
depiction of Amon Goeth, the concentration camp commandant. He’s
the only Nazi we get to know in the film, and, thanks to Ralph Fiennes’s
terrifying performance, he comes across as a psychopath (and as
a convenient stand-in for Hitler). The implication is that the Nazi
horror was perpetuated by people like Goeth, and was not the responsibility
of the German people or the result of a national xenophobia that
clearly still exists today. If those who do not remember history
are doomed to repeat it, this type of portrayal is particularly
dangerous. After all, a whole generation will probably grow up learning
about the Holocaust from Schindler’s List, (especially if
it wins the Best Picture Oscar, which it is clearly poised to do),
and the lessons the film teaches, it seems to me, are not nearly
strong enough.

Or is this merely my own bias? As
I wrote at the beginning of this piece, the way we view a given
film often tells us more about ourselves than it does about the
film in question. Perhaps the film’s ultimate optimism about humanity
simply doesn’t jibe with my more pessimistic views. At any rate,
it’s unquestionably a good thing that Spielberg made it. Better
that a generation should grow up learning about the Holocaust from
this film than not at all. Furthermore, the film’s commercial and
critical success may well open the door for other filmmakers to
examine the horrors of the Holocaust. Like his Schindler, Spielberg
may not have done all he could to save the world (though, judging
by the tone of his interviews, he doesn’t seem to realize it), but
he has at least made a noble effort, which is far more than most
moviemakers can claim. MM

Continue Reading
Advertisement
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More in Articles - Directing

  • Articles - Acting

    Editor’s Weekend Pick: Short Term 12

    By

    MovieMaker‘s pick of the films out in theaters this week is the award-winning, heart-pumping Short Term...

  • Articles - Acting

    Fictionalizing Truth: Lee Daniel’s The Butler & More

    By

    We’ve all seen those stately biopics (usually with Oscar aspirations), in which renowned actors portray real-life...

  • Articles

    MovieMaker Editor’s Pick: Prince Avalanche
    by MovieMaker Editors

    By

    MovieMaker’s Editor’s Weekend Pick is director-writer-producer David Gordon Green’s Prince Avalanche, starring Paul Rudd and Emile...

  • Articles

    Thor Freudenthal Sets Sail with Percy Jackson: Sea of Monsters
    by Kyle Rupprecht

    By

    German-born moviemaker Thor Freudenthal started his career in visual effects and animation, working on such films...

  • Articles - Cinematography

    Best Of: The Most Bodacious Surfing Movies

    By

    Much like an ocean wave, the surfing movie subgenre has seen its share of peaks and...

  • Articles

    Tattoo Nation: Director Eric Schwartz (Part 2)

    By

    In Part One (of this interview, we talked to Colorado-based Tattoo Nation director Eric Schwartz about...

  • Articles - Directing

    Things I’ve Learned As a Moviemaker: Kevin Smith

    By

    Director, screenwriter, sometimes actor, and all-around major geek Kevin Smith has deep roots in independent moviemaking,...

  • Articles - Acting

    Perfectly Paranormal: Ghostbusting in Film

    By

    Where would the world be without the paranormal investigators of cinema? Overrun with evil spirits, demons...

  • Articles

    MovieMaker Editor’s Weekend Pick: Storm Surfers 3D
    by Rory Owen Delaney

    By

    Storm Surfers 3D delivers big wave-riding experience for moviegoers!  This week’s MovieMaker Editor’s Weekend Pick is...

  • Articles

    Laurence Anyways: MovieMaker’s Weekend Pick
    by Kelly Leow

    By

    In recognition of the Supreme Court’s landmark dismissal of California’s Proposition 8 and its striking down...

  • Articles - Directing

    Things I’ve Learned: Neil Jordan’s 12 Golden Rules of Moviemaking

    By

    In the last few years, Neil Jordan, whose career spans three decades, has written and directed...

  • Articles - Directing

    Re-Vamping: Ten Unique Takes on Vampire Mythology

    By

    In celebration of the release of “Byzantium” this Friday, we’ve come up with a selection of...

  • Articles - Directing

    Things I’ve Learned: Gus Van Sant’s Six Golden Rules of Moviemaking

    By

    Gus Van Sant is one of America’s most heralded, iconic independent auteurs.  Based in Portland, Oregon,...

  • Articles - Acting

    Sloppy Seconds: The Best (and Worst) Horror Remakes

    By

    Horror movie remakes are a dime a dozen these days, with retreads of such genre classics...

  • To Top