Wolfwalkers is a unique feat in animation: A majority of the animation was hand-drawn, either on physical paper or using computer illustrators, and the film uses 3D elements that mix seamlessly with what’s often called “2D” — though co-director Tomm Moore isn’t in love with the term.
“2D is the worst phrase ever. It’s hand-drawn. It’s not 2D. Everyone says 2D — I do as well,” Moore said in a Q&A Monday about the film. “It’s three-dimensional, sometimes it’s two-and-half-D for some of the Mosaic background characters.”
Moore and Wolfwalkers co-director Ross Stewart were on hand, along with many of their collaborators, to discuss the challenges they faced. The film, released in November on Apple TV+, comes from Irish animation studio Cartoon Saloon.
“I think that one of the challenges, was that even if we were drawing a lot from the original Cartoon Saloon film style, there was also clear intention to push it further, so in some instances it even got flatter than before,” said character designer Federico Pirovano. “For example, if you look at background characters, they are almost similar to Mosaics instead.”
Pirovano continued: “But, if you look at most of the characters, they often are a bit more two-dimensional than in previous movies. But at the same time we didn’t want to go fully two-dimensional. We spent some time searching for a balance between the two, where we had to decide arbitrarily which lines would represent a 3D volume and which others instead we would flatten, and make it perfectly graphical.”
Moore said the directors asked their collaborators to invest their own personalities into the story.
“The big ask we had of everyone was that they approach it as filmmakers, and bring something of themselves to it,” Moore said. “Each department was passing the baton creatively and trying to work toward creating something cohesive that looks like it was drawn by one hand.”
Exclusive concept art of the Wolfvision in Wolfwalkers. Wolfvision uses one of the three unique line styles in the film. Concept art by Flora Taverner / Courtesy of Apple
There are three different line styles present in Wolfwalkers, clean-up artist Tatiana Mazzei explained.
“Besides trying to get the characters looking bright, and like they’re being drawn by the same person — basically keeping it consistent, you’re worried about the lines. There’s two different line styles, plus the ‘wolfvision’ style, so there’s three different styles in there, so there were whole line styles that had to be created just for that. We had to get these flat characters and make them move in a 3D space as well … it’s a big challenge.”
Moore chimed in to explain that normally the clean line department would be “asked to be consistent with the line, whereas for this, we wanted a lot of variation and for them to think a little bit like comic-book inkers or picture-book illustrators, where their line would adapt depending on the mood of the character or the area and the environment that they were from.”
Watch the full Wolfwalkers talk here:
Wolfwalkers is currently available to stream on Apple TV+.
Young Frankenstein, which turns 50 this year, is at or near the top of any…
Before Martin Short came to play Ned Nederlander, one of the three titular amigos opposite…
Is your nostalgia a crutch? Or a doorway to liberation? That’s the question asked by…
Here are 10 jaw-dropping Pixar jokes clearly aimed at moms and dads and grandparents, not…
Marlon Wayans says producers Bob and Harvey Weinstein "raped" him and his family out of…
These 10 mob movie slang terms will be familiar only to true fans of gangster…
View Comments
Totally agree with Tomm Moore on this. Traditional Animation, Hand Drawn Animation, Pencil Animation, are all better terms than "2D Animation". The veteran animation designer and director Gene Deitch made similar comments in an address he made to an international animation festival held in China. His talks was titled "Quo Vadis Anmation?". At one point he says:
"I am here to raise a cheer for what I prefer to call Drawn Animation. We who have been raised on the tradition of animated drawings, attempting create what Frank Thomas and Ollie Johnston called, “The Illusion of Life,” have been more and more pushed aside and given the demeaning title of “2D” animators. I am quick to remind you that anything projected onto a flat movie screen is essentially 2D. It’s a meaningless term. I repeat that the entire world of graphic art, every drawn or painted style can be animated in any fanciful way, which in turn would lead to the widest range of storytelling and endless visual variety."
https://www.cartoonbrew.com/ideas-commentary/gene-deitch-quo-vadis-animation-18033.html