Toni Williams in Secret Admirer (Played by Lori Loughlin)

When Michael Ryan (C. Thomas Howell) receives an anonymous love letter, he assumes its from his blonde crush Deborah (Kelly Preston). But it’s actually from his good friend Toni, who is, in a twist you will never see coming, a brunette.

Through a series of misunderstandings, things escalate, and Michael eventually realizes that Deb is a bit shallow and that he and Toni, of course, belong together. Of course.