MovieMaker The Art and Business of Making Movies » Login | Register  

May 26, 2012

ABOUT | CONTACT | NEWSLETTER | Search

directing

Email
Print

Bulletproof on Broadway

(Page 2)

The film was so painfully personal it would have been difficult to watch under any circumstances. But with Allen, Farrow and her brood of children on the nightly news as constant reminders of his indiscretion, audiences steered clear of Husband and Wives. Those who did come were forced to deal with their own conflicting emotions. It was impossible to react to Husbands and Wives strictly as a work of art.

“Laughter, remaining subconscious in its manifest realm (or as Freud put it, when it comes out of the mouth), often works best after something funny has happened. That is why the death of a friend almost never gets a chuckle but a funny hat does—"Woody, the Would-Be Critic.”

After the box office failure of Husband and Wives, there were those who thought Allen’s career would be over. At least since Annie Hall, Allen has been one of the few moviemakers in this country who maintains absolute control over his films—Steven Spielberg is the only other who comes readily to mind—and he has resolutely declared that if he cannot make films on his own terms, he’ll retire and write novels. But unlike Spielberg, who earned his level of control by making more money than any moviemaker in history, Allen’s carte blanche was the direct result of the high moral standing he had as America’s resident auteur—a position his idealized relationship with Farrow quietly reinforced. 

He was too good for Hollywood, and Hollywood knew it. He didn’t even need to show up at the Oscars; he won three of them without missing his regular Monday night clarinet gig at Michael’s Pub.

But now that Allen was unable to serve as an aesthetic and moral spokesperson for the film industry, many speculated that his financing would dry up. That, the thinking went, was why he re-teamed with Diane Keaton for Manhattan Murder Mystery, a lightweight farce that had none of the bite of his best work. Was he trying to appease his fans with a return to the style of his “early, funny films?” Perhaps. But it wasn’t a hit either, and when TriStar announced that Allen would be leaving the studio to make independently financed films, there were those who thought Allen’s career might be over.

Not to worry: His friend Jean Doumanian, a former executive producer of “Saturday Night Live,” came through with European financing that would ensure Allen the non-negotiable absolute control over his work that he’s enjoyed since Annie Hall elevated him from mere comic genius to auteur nearly two decade ago. Will Bullets Over Broadway be a hit? Probably not. The good news is it probably doesn’t matter; the European financing seems set for years to come, and anyway, Allen’s films make back their money in Europe. And yes, Bullets Over Broadway is a lot of fun. For those of you who especially loved his “early, funny” movies, it may even be a welcome return to form.

“You’re not Superman, you’re a comedian. You want to do mankind a service? Tell funnier jokes.”—Alien to Sandy Bates in Stardust Memories.

At least on the surface, one would be hard-pressed to call Bullets Over Broadway autobiographical. Set in New York in the 1920s, it tells the story of David Shayne, a young playwright who is forced to cast a gangster’s moll in his new play in order to gain financing. Yet with his hesitant manner and worried New York accent, John Cusack, who plays Shayne, sounds like a young Woody Allen. Indeed, even within the construct of this deliberately lightweight film, there are parallels with Allen’s recent travails.

When Shayne, who’s been cheating on his girlfriend with the star of his play, visits his mentor, Sheldon Flender, in search of moral advice, Flender tells him: “An artist creates his own moral universe. You gotta do what you gotta do.” It’s a line that recalls Allen’s character’s self-justification in Husbands and Wives: “My heart does not know from logic.” Or, as the man himself told Time magazine when his affair with Soon-Yi became public knowledge: “The heart wants what it wants.”

Allen, as it happens, doesn’t play Flender—Rob Reiner does—but he could have. The irony would have been pretty thick, especially when it turns out that Flender himself is having an affair with the girlfriend Shayne’s been betraying. In a way, these ironies double our enjoyment of the film; we feel like we’re in on something. The same was not true about the more contextually blatant ironies of Husbands and Wives. There was an almost overwhelming feeling of discomfort in the theater when Husbands and Wives played, and audiences laughed nervously at all the inappropriate moments.

That was two years ago now, and in the interim Allen has made two new films. Granted, neither one was a great film, but that’s par for the course. Between Stardust Memories and Hannah and Her Sisters, there were A Midsummer Night’s Sex Comedy, Broadway Danny Rose, Zelig and The Purple Rose of Cairo. Likewise, between Hannah and Crimes and Misdemeanors, and between Crimes and Husbands and Wives, there were somewhat lesser films.

Allen has already started another film titled, like all his works in progress, Woody Allen’s Fall Project, after the season in which he starts filming. Will it be a great film? It’s impossible to say, but that the question even arises is testament to his genius. And even if it’s not a great film, it’ll be a welcome relief from whatever else is out there; year in and year out, that’s something his fans have come to count on. For Woody Allen is not only one of our best moviemakers, he’s also our most prolific one—a rare combination. Whatever his private faults, we’re lucky to have him. 


SHARE THIS STORY

Del.icio.us this itemDel.icio.us

Reddit this itemReddit

Yahoo this item Yahoo

TAGS

COMMENTS | POST A COMMENT

Comment by العاب on 5/31/11 at 7:51 pm

Thanks for providing such a العاب تلبيس بنات تلبيس مكياج  حلوة وجديدة تحميل العاب تلبيس

POST A COMMENT

OUR PRIVACY POLICY | We will not publish or sell or share your email address or other personal information. Read more.

Name:  
Email:  
URL:  

Type the word you see below:

Comment:

MovieMaker Magazine

Magazine cover: November 1994This story was published in the November 1994 MovieMaker Magazine. The headline was:

Bulletproof on Broadway/There were those who thought his career was over, but Woody Allen survives and proves again that even at his worst, he's one of the best.

View this issue

Order this issue | Subscribe to MM

 

Blog/Forum/Poll navigation

Blog Forums Polls
Latest from the blog:
 

Blog

SITE DELIVERY OPTIONS

ALSO IN THIS ISSUE

  1. Bulletproof on Broadway
    There were those who thought his career was over, but with Bullets Over Broadway Woody Allen survived and proved again that even at his worst, he's one of the ... read on
  2. Clerks Proves Ignorance is Bliss
    With no budget and a toy slate, Kevin Smith and Scott Mosier show all you really need are ... read on
  3. Lessons From Orson
    One of Orson Welle's closest friends in his later years, Henry Jaglom shares advice from his mentor. Plus, a review of a "new" Welles ... read on
  4. What Do Distributors Want From Us, Anyway?
    The second installment on our continuing series on "How to Avoid Distribution Hell." This time we talk to four ... read on
  5. Confessions of the Adrenaline Junkies
    Stuntmen and women are the unsung heroes of the motion picture industry. Why do they do ... read on
  6. Sound Acting Advice
    Establishing and training your voice can mean a potentially lucrative supplement to your acting ... read on
  7. Tough Gal Faye Dunaway Keeps Going with Arizona Dream
    Despite her status as a film legend, American studios still seems reluctant to release Dunaway's finely crafted and low-profile "art" ... read on
  8. Carty Talkington Hits the Mark with Love and a .45
    In Love and a .45, writer-director Carty Talkington has created a stylized, darkly comedic journey through the contemporary American landscape of murder, media, music, controlled substances and unbridled love. ... read on
  9. Tom Noonan Tries to Figure Out What Happened
    Financed with his own money, actor and first-time director Tom Noonan's What Happened Was... has become another 1994 indie success story. ... read on
  10. Fresh Director Boaz Yakin Proves You Can Make it Sans the Hype
    Fresh is a knockout of a first film. Well-crafted and poetically paced, it is a movie so simple and straightforward in storyline that it feels like a completely “fresh” approach to moviemaking. So how did director ... read on
  11. In My Japanese Cousin, The Talent’s in the Music
    Maria Garguilo finds the Seattle scene a source of fledgling actors and cheap labor for her first feature, The Year of My Japanese ... read on
  12. MM Notebook
    At the risk of sounding irritatingly cheerleaderesque, this month I had a notion to devote my few hundred words of spout-off space to the public’s receptiveness to independent moviemaking in this country. There is ... read on
  13. Reviews: Ed Wood Have Been Proud
    Tim Burton, who gave the horror genre a “Leave it to Beaver” twist with Frankenweenie, made Paul Reubens a role model in Pee Wee’s Big Adventure and added a hint of menace to Batman, has moved beyond TV-land ... read on

RELATED ARTICLES FROM THE ARCHIVES

  1. 5/24/2012: James Franco vs. the Fact Checkers Unit
  2. 5/21/2012: Having Big Fun in the Big Town
  3. 5/10/2012: “It’s Only Forever…”
  4. 5/3/2012: Water Takes Center Stage in Last Call at the Oasis
  5. 4/27/2012: Over the Rainbow with Jonathan Kalafer