MovieMaker The Art and Business of Making Movies » Login | Register  

May 25, 2012

ABOUT | CONTACT | NEWSLETTER | Search

directing

Email
Print

Rus Raves and Rants

The Best and Worst of 1997 on Video

Cyclo

The Best

Cyclo - There is not a wasted image in this film from Vietnamese director Hung Tran Anh (The Scent of Green Papaya). Scenes of transfixing beauty and startling brutality blend seamlessly to form an hallucinatory narrative, an almost psychotic meditation on a culture and people struggling through their capitalist evolution. Hung is not so concerned with plot mechanicsthe story, about a young cyclo (pronounced SEEK-low) driver who is forced into a gang to keep his job, is disjointed and at times confusing. But the director uses color like an abstract expressionist; he prefers bold, extreme close-ups to standard wide shots. He will someday make a masterpiece. Cyclo comes pretty close to being one.

Small Faces - This Scottish film, directed by Gillies MacKinnon and written by the director and his brother, Billy, also takes a sobering look at a young man lured into gang life. The elliptical story takes place in 1968 and is anchored by the remarkable performance of Iain Robertson, a teenager at war with his older brother and his hormones. MacKinnon's camera moves with a mesmerizing glide; he discovers angles that depict a working class world that is both monstrous and, at times, strangely alluring. An underrated gem.

Casino - Paranoia, treachery, desire. Martin Scor- sese works this territory like a pit boss. Casino was criticized for its length and repetitiveness, but that is exactly why it worked for me. It played like a long night at the blackjack table, an epic descent into the base arena of greed, where deceit can be exposed with a simple wink. Robert De Niro, Sharon Stone, and Joe Pesci are a trio of lowlifes who get to play dress-up until they begin to tumble, step-by-inexorable-step. Scorsese tracks their fall with a trance-like precision while getting powerful performances, especially from De Niro, who plays the last hour of the film in a bathrobe and slippers.

Dead Man - Speaking of trances, Jim Jarmusch made the cinematic equivalent of Tuvan throat-singing with this gorgeous black-and-white western. It's a deeply mystical exploration of identity and death, rooted in a wintry, wooded landscape, grounded by the mesmerizing junkyard growl of Neil Young's guitar. A film of exotic power.

Breaking the Waves

Lone Star - John Sayles writes so well that you believe everything his characters say; you believe their life stories, you understand their reasons without having them pointed out to you. Chris Cooper and Elizabeth Pena are excellent as tentative lovers separated by the past, by prejudices, and by an odd paternity. They unravel a Texas community's secret history while attempting to hold together the fragile present. A mature, subtle, engrossing film from one of our best filmmakers.

Hard Eight - In just two films, Paul Thomas Anderson has established himself as a director of vision. It's clear with Hard Eight and Boogie Nights that he is concerned with survivalthe people who practice it and the tools they useand with the paternal instinct, the ways older men can sweep the young under a fatherly wing. With Boogie Nights it's Burt Reynolds' soft-hearted porn king; here it's Phillip Baker Hall's aging gambler. He is a man who survives through patience, by waiting for the right roll, by working a system just enough. It is a testament to Anderson's trust in his own story that he delivers his climaxes quietly. This is the best American debut film in years. It's dynamite with a slow fuse.

When We Were Kings - We are so lucky that Mu- hammad Ali let director Leon Gast into his training camp for the famous "Rumble in the Jungle" in 1974. Now we have this funny, moving, electric portrait of one of America's true originals, who believes to this day that the measure of a man is in his humanity, his ability to say what he means, his willingness to take risks, look foolish, and most importantly, to have a sense of humor. Interviews with Norman Mailer and George Plimpton make you love the fight; Ali makes you love the man.

Flirt

Breaking the Waves - Lars Von Trier's film is a hybrid, a sort of fictional verité that shows what happens when a woman takes her religion too seriously. It's a devastating story of love and sacrifice, shot by Robby Muller with a roughnecked, hand-held style as rocky as the Scottish coastline where it's set. Emily Watson and Stellan Skarsgard are sad and real and erotic as the tragic couple.

Flirt (Part 1) - Hal Hartley's latest was actually three films in one, an experiment that went horribly wrong (see Worst). Part I works because of Hartley's absurdist Zen dialogue, the way he introduces characters and locations as if he lifts a curtain and reveals them posing for us, and the complete unpredictability of his plots. Flirt, Part I is hilarious and knowing; one giddy surprise after another.

The Worst

Flirt (Parts II and III) - It must have seemed like a radical cinematic idea at the time, but when Part II of Hartley's triptych comes up it's clear that the fun of the movie is over. The technical exercise that follows is such a film school bore that you desperately start fast-forwarding to find the next good scene until you realize it doesn't exist. The idea, to have three different sets of characters in three different settings repeat the same exact dialogue must have looked good scrawled on a cocktail napkin, but on the screen it's an excruciating, Mondrian-like attempt to paint the same box over and over again. Nice try, Hal, but don't go there again.

The Spitfire Grill - First Sundance gave it an award, then CastleRock Entertainment spent 10 million for the rights. Wow, what an embarrassment! Did they really think they could market this slice of Sunday school dreck to an art house audience and force them to swallow it? Spitfire featured enough scenery chewing to make John Malkovich turn in his knife and fork. Ellen Burstyn slobbed around in a house dress and Marcia Gay Harden was so mousy I thought she was going to start squeaking. Come on, a whole movie built around the dramatic intrigue of an essay contest?

ll Postino - I try to give a wide berth to any film that captures the ignominious title of "Highest Grossing Foreign Film of All Time." That means two things: first, it is written, directed, and acted to appeal to the broadest possible American audience, i.e. all of those people who think subtitles are the gas mileage information they put on the bottom of car commercials; and second, it sucks! Does anyone remember The Gods Must Be Crazy, Like Water For Chocolate, Cinema Paradiso? The fact that audiences flock to these movies like lemmings makes me want to take a long Peckinpah- vian piss on the screen. I've seen tourist snapshots with more artfulness than the shaky, flat cinematography of this film. Director Michael Rad-ford (1984), lurches through the story like a drunk looking for a place to sleep it off. What a cheap, unfocused, poorly cut, sentimental little mess.

Touch - Paul Schrader has never really made a great film, but now at least he has made an extraordinarily bad one. Touch, based on an El-more Leonard novel, unfortunately has none of the snap you might expect from the author's dialogue, and the movie is absolutely bereft of any sizzle, attitude, or momentum. I just don't think Leonard transfers well to film (even Tarantino's Jackie Brown, based on Leonard's "Rum Punch," is dreary, flat, and slooooow). Touch also suffers from the musical kiss of death: a goofy doop-de-doo soundtrack that never stops, that drains the irony and comedy from every scene. A stupendously silly bore.

Space Jam - I usually swim clear of the mainstream with this year-end list, but this was such an egregious example of the eight-year-old male mentality that drives Hollywood these days that I couldn't pass it up. Since I can't remember a single scene, moment, character, line, or shot of this worthless tripe, isn't that enough of a reason to burn director Joe Pytka at the stake? Wait, I do recall Bill Murray literally wandering into the film at the end for no apparent reason other than to show that a middle-age white guy with a beer gut can definitely not jump, and I remember thinking Charles Barkley should stick to throwing guys through windows. It couldn't be as painful as watching him act.

She's The One - Since we've already got the fire lit for Pytka, keep it blazing for Edward Burns, leader of the indie-lite movement, in which 20-something directors write puffy little romantic comedies, shoot them cheap, get their three-picture deals and then, whaddayaknowevery picture looks just like the last one (Kevin Smith's Chasing Amy, anybody?). Burns doesn't possess one molecule of filmmaking intelligence. He doesn't know where to put or when to move his camera, how to compose or choreograph a shot, or how to get his actors to believe a word of what they're saying. He thinks infidelity is a million laughs and love only happens when cued to a soundtrack. What this guy knows about relationships you can etch onto the nub of a pencil.

Nowhere - What would a year-end worst list be without Gregg Araki? MM


SHARE THIS STORY

Del.icio.us this itemDel.icio.us

Reddit this itemReddit

Yahoo this item Yahoo

TAGS

COMMENTS | POST A COMMENT

POST A COMMENT

OUR PRIVACY POLICY | We will not publish or sell or share your email address or other personal information. Read more.

Name:  
Email:  
URL:  

Type the word you see below:

Comment:

MovieMaker Magazine

Magazine cover: April 1998This story was published in the April 1998 MovieMaker Magazine. The headline was:

Rus Raves and Rants / The Best and Worst of 1997 on Video

View this issue

Order this issue | Subscribe to MM

 

Blog/Forum/Poll navigation

Blog Forums Polls
Latest from the blog:
 

Blog

SITE DELIVERY OPTIONS

News Feed

  

Newsletter

ALSO IN THIS ISSUE

  1. Smart, Clean, Raw
    What an indie movie should ... read on
  2. Lesli Linka Glatter
    A conversation with Lesli Linka Glatter, director of the indie film, The ... read on
  3. MovieMaker Breakthrough Award Winners Tell Their Stories
    Done's Sand Trap wins at Hollywood Film Festival and Higby's Matters of Consequence wins at New Orleans film Festival. Read how these indie filmmakers survived and flourished in the grinding ordeal of low-budget ... read on
  4. Julia Stiles
    A veteran at the tender age of sixteen, Julia Stiles tells MovieMaker how she's working her way into The ... read on
  5. Rus Raves and Rants
    The best and worst of 1997 on video. Indie writer and director, Rus Thompson, reviews 14 indie films of transfixing beauty and mystical exploration as well as some flops that are embarrassing to ... read on
  6. Letters
    ... read on
  7. Up and Away with Michael Apted
    The acclaimed, enigmatic British director of the 28-Up series reflects on his career and his unique new documentary film, ... read on

RELATED ARTICLES FROM THE ARCHIVES

  1. 5/24/2012: James Franco vs. the Fact Checkers Unit
  2. 5/21/2012: Having Big Fun in the Big Town
  3. 5/14/2012: Dark Shadows Can't Bring Down The Avengers
  4. 5/10/2012: “It’s Only Forever…”
  5. 5/7/2012: Avengers Assemble at the Box Office